Overview 

This addition will allow users to see the history of directives made to a column of data.

Goals

User should be able to see lineage information, ie. directives, for columns

Storing lineage information should have minimal/no impact to the wrangler application

User Stories

• As a user, I should be able to see the directives applied to a column of data.

• As a user, I should be able to see the directives applied to a column of data over any period of time.

• As a user, I should be able to see how any column got to its current state as well as other columns that were impacted by it

• As a user, I should be able to add tags and properties to specific columns of data (stretch)

Design

Save directives for each column in AST format after parsing of directives along with necessary information (time, dataset/stream name/id, etc.).Use TMS input and output schemas.

prepareRun() api to send information to platform.

***release 4.Unmarshal 4 onwards implementations can be found in branches feature/implement-transform-publishLineage and feature/field-level-lineage***

Unmarshall and connect into graph and store in HBase.

Access to lineage should only be available through the platform

Questions

• How to get source and sink datasets?
• Does ParseTree have all necessary information for every directive?

Approach

Approach #1:

Store directives during execution of each step

Advantages:

• Less assumptions

Disadvantages:

• Add getter to each step class + sometimes (~30%) local variable
• Slower

Approach #2 (Preferred):

Compute lineage without looking at data by backtracking

Advantages:

• No instance variables added to step classes
• Faster

Disadvantages:

• Requires stricter rule on directives, ie. every rename must give old and new name. See * below for why
• More assumption based, ie. parse-as-<> assumes that the output fields are from all the input fields

*Backtrack starting with columns A,B,C. Previous directive is "set-columns A B C". The directive before that is "filter-row-if-matched <column> <regex>" where <column> is nameOfOwner. No way of knowing what nameOfOwner refers to without looking at data.

API changes

New Programmatic APIs

FieldLevelLineage Java class that contains all necessary information to be sent to CDAP platform

Instance should be initialized passing in list of final columns after wrangling.

Approach

• Each directive implements `public MutationDefinition lineage()`
• prepareRun() function in Wrangler.java creates FieldLevelLineage instance and sends it to CDAP
• CDAP receives all instances of FieldLevelLineage from all transform stages and takes 4 variables to build graph:
  • ProgramRunId
  • PipelinePhase
  • Mapping of stage name to FieldLevelLineage for all transform stages
  • Mapping of stage name to Dataset name for sources and sinks
• Graph is generated and stored in HBase in a way that is easily accessible to UI

API changes

New Programmatic APIs:

TransformStep:

TransformStep is a Java interface that represents a modification done to a dataset by a transform stage.

/**
 * <p>
 *   A TransformStep represents a modification done by a Transform.
 * </p>
 */
public interface TransformStep {

  /**
   * @return the name of this modification
   */
  String getName();

  /**
   * @return additional information about this modification
   */
  @Nullable
  String getInformation();
}

FieldLevelLineage:

FieldLevelLineage is a Java interface that contains all the necessary field-level lineage information to be sent to the CDAP platform, for transform stages.

import java.util.List;
import java.util.Map;

/**
 * <p>FieldLevelLineage is a DataType for computing lineage for each field in a dataset.
 * An instance of this type can be sent to be sent to platform through API for transform stages.</p>
 */
public interface FieldLevelLineage {

  /**
   * <p>A BranchingTransformStepNode represents a linking between a {@link TransformStep} and a field of data.
   * It contains data about how this TransformStep affected this field.</p>
   */
  interface BranchingTransformStepNode {

    /**
     * @return the index of the TransformStep in {@link #getSteps()}
     */
    int getTransformStepNumber();

    /**
     * @return true if this TransformStep does not add this field
     */
    boolean continueBackward(); // continue down

    /**
     * @return true if this TransformStep does not drop this field
     */
    boolean continueForward();  // continue up

    /**
     * This map should contain every other field that was impacted by this field in this TransformStep
     * @return A map from field name to the index of the next TransformStep using {@link #getLineage()}
     * Usage: getLineage().get(field).get(index).
     */
    Map<String, Integer> getImpactedBranches();  // getUpBranches

    /**
     * This map should contain every other field that impacted this field with this TransformStep
     * @return A map from field name to the index of the previous transformation step in {@link #getLineage()}
     * Usage: getLineage().get(field).get(index).
     */
    Map<String, Integer> getImpactingBranches();  // getDownBranches
  }

  /**
   * @return a list of all TransformSteps executed by this Transform in order.
   */
  List<TransformStep> getSteps();

  /**
   * @return a mapping of field names to a list of {@link BranchingTransformStepNode} in reverse order.
   */
  Map<String, List<BranchingTransformStepNode>> getLineage();
}

WranglerFieldLevelLineage:

Instance should be initialized per wrangler node passing in a list of start and end columns (input and output schema).

build() takes a List<MutationDefinition> and stores all the necessary information into lineages.

Stores lineage for each column in lineage instance variable which is a map to ASTs.

/**
 * WranglerFieldLevelLineage is a data type for computing lineage for all columns in Wrangler.
 * An instance of this type to be sent to platform through prepareRun API.
 */
public final class WranglerFieldLevelLineage implements FieldLevelLineage {
  /**
    private class BranchingStepNode {
* A WranglerBranchingStepNode is a data type for linking columns to directives as well as other columns.
   */
  public final class WranglerBranchingStepNode implements BranchingTransformStepNode {
    private final int stepNumber;
    private boolean continueUp;
    private boolean continueDown;
    Step directive;private final Map<String, Integer> upBranches;
    private final Map<String, Integer> branchesdownBranches;

    private WranglerBranchingStepNode(int stepNumber, //boolean constructorscontinueUp, toString()boolean continueDown) {
   }   privatethis.stepNumber String= dataSetNamestepNumber;
// dataset/stream name/id   private finalthis.continueUp long= startTimecontinueUp;
    private  finalthis.continueDown String= programNamecontinueDown;
      privatethis.upBranches final= String[] finalColumnsnew HashMap<>();
  private final Set<String> currentColumns; // not sure if needed depending on parse tree implementation
  private final Map<String, List<BranchingStepNode>> lineage; // main storage    this.downBranches = new HashMap<>();
    }
	
	// Internal functions

    @Override
    public int getTransformStepNumber() {
      return stepNumber;
    }

    @Override
    public boolean continueBackward() {
      return continueUp;
    }

    @Override
    public FieldLevelLineage(String dataSetName, String[] columnNames) {...boolean continueForward() {
      return continueDown;
    }

    @Override
    public Map<String, Integer> getImpactedBranches() {
      return Collections.unmodifiableMap(downBranches);
    }

  // getters for startTime, programName, dataSetName, finalColumns
  // setter for dataSetName  
 
  // Helpers for store  @Override
    public Map<String, Integer> getImpactingBranches() {
      return Collections.unmodifiableMap(upBranches);
    }

    @Override
    public voidString storetoString(ParseTree tree) {
      return "(StepNumber: " + stepNumber List<String>+ readCols, addCols, modifyCols, dropCols, renameCols, swapCols;
	/**
     * Go through tree one directive at a time
     * For each column associated with the directive put name of column into associated list based on label 
     * From these 6 lists store correctly into lineage
	 */
  }
}

", Continue Backward: " + continueUp + ", " + upBranches +
          ", Continue Forward: " + continueDown + ", " + downBranches + ")";
    }
  }

  private final List<TransformStep> steps;
  private final Map<String, List<BranchingTransformStepNode>> lineage;


  // Internal functions

  // Shows lineage in tree format
  void prettyPrint(String column, boolean forward) {...}

  @Override
  public List<TransformStep> getSteps() {
    return Collections.unmodifiableList(this.steps);
  }

  @Override
  public Map<String, List<BranchingTransformStepNode>> getLineage() {
    return Collections.unmodifiableMap(this.lineage);
  }

  @Override
  public String toString() {
    return "Column Directives: " + lineage + "\n" + "Steps: " + steps;
  }

  /**
   * Builder class for {@link WranglerFieldLevelLineage}.
   */
  public static class Builder {
    // Internal functions
	public Builder(List<String> startColumns, List<String> finalColumns) {...}
    public WranglerFieldLevelLineage build(List<MutationDefinition> parseTree) throws LineageGenerationException {...}
  }
}

parseTree should contain all columns affected per directive.

Labels:

• All columns should be labeled one of:  {Read, Drop, Modify, Add,

• Rename}

• Read: column's name or values are read

• . Including reading values and modifying. ie. "filter-rows-on..."
• Drop: column is dropped

• Add: column is added

• Rename: column's name is

• replaced with

• another name
• Modify: column's

• values altered and doesn't fit in any of the other categories, ie. "lowercase"

For Read, Drop, Modify, and Add , the column and associated label should be something like this -> Column: Name, Label: add.

For Swap, Rename, Rename the column and associated label should be something like this  -> Column: body_5 DOB, Label: rename. // Basically some way of having both names, currently using a space. Old/new for rename. Swap example: A B, Label: rename and B A, Label: rename.

**Assumption (can be changed): In ParseTree all columns should be in order of impact. ie. If directive is "copy A A_copy". "A, A/B for swapLabel: read" should be before "A_copy, Label: add".

Algorithm visual:  lineage ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------->     List for name column  -------------->  Example wrangler applicationImage Removed     Image Removed  Image Removed Example wrangler application                                                                                     -->      forward lineage           -->                   backward lineage  

Image Added Image Added Image Added

FieldLevelLineageStorageNode (IN BRANCH feature/field-level-lineage-storage):

FieldLevelLineageStorageNode is a Java interface that represents an element being stored in HBase.

These nodes are created and connected in an AST format by FieldLevelLineageStorageGraph.

/**
 * <p>A FieldLevelLineageStorageNode represents a node of field-level lineage information.</p>
 */
public interface FieldLevelLineageStorageNode {

  /**
   * @return the ID of the pipeline
   */
  ProgramRunId getPipeline();

  /**
   * @return the name of the stage
   */
  String getStage();

  /**
   * @return the name of the field
   */
  String getField();
}

FieldLevelLineageStorageGraph (IN BRANCH feature/field-level-lineage-storage):

FieldLevelLineageStorageGraph is a Java class that transforms many instances of FieldLevelLineage into a graph of FieldLevelLineageStorageNodes for storage.

One instance of this type should be created per pipeline. Created from many instances of FieldLevelLineage, some graph representation of the pipeline, a mapping between reference names and stage names for sources/sinks, and ProgramRunId.

import com.google.common.collect.ArrayListMultimap;
import com.google.common.collect.HashBasedTable;
import com.google.common.collect.ListMultimap;
import com.google.common.collect.Table;

import java.util.HashMap;
import java.util.List;
import java.util.Map;

public final class FieldLevelLineageStorageGraph {
  private final ProgramRunId pipelineId;
  private final PipelinePhase pipeline; // Or another type of graph of the pipeline
  private final Map<String, FieldLevelLineage> stages;
  private final Map<String, String> stageToDataSet;
  private final Map<FieldLevelLineageStorageNode, FieldLevelLineageStorageNode> nodeRetriever;
  private final Table<String, String, DataSetFieldNode> history; // Storage
  private final Map<FieldStepNode, TransformStep> stepInformation; // Storage
  private final ListMultimap<FieldLevelLineageStorageNode, FieldLevelLineageStorageNode> pastEdges; // Storage
  private final ListMultimap<FieldLevelLineageStorageNode, FieldLevelLineageStorageNode> futureEdges; // Storage

  public FieldLevelLineageStorageGraph(ProgramRunId PipelineId, PipelinePhase pipeline,
                                       Map<String, FieldLevelLineage> stages, Map<String, String> stageToDataSet) {
    this.pipelineId = PipelineId;
    this.pipeline = pipeline;
    this.stages = stages;
    this.stageToDataSet = stageToDataSet;
    this.nodeRetriever = new HashMap<>();
    this.history = HashBasedTable.create();
    this.stepInformation = new HashMap<>();
    this.pastEdges = ArrayListMultimap.create();
    this.futureEdges = ArrayListMultimap.create();
  }

  // helpers for make()

  private void make() {...} // makes the graph
}

Visual:

  Image Added  

Publishing Lineage Information:

Will be done through new prepareRun() function in the Transform class and new recordLineage(FieldLevelLineage f) function in StageSubmitter interface. Each transform plugin stage will have option to publish field-level lineage.

Wrangler Example:

...
@Override
public void prepareRun(StageSubmitter<TransformContext> context) throws Exception {
  if (context.getContext().getArguments().has("enable.wrangler.field.lineage")) {
    List<String> startColumns, endColumns;
    Schema inputSchema, outputSchema;
    inputSchema = context.getContext().getInputSchema();
    outputSchema = context.getContext().getOutputSchema();
    if (inputSchema == null || inputSchema.getFields() == null) {
      startColumns = new ArrayList<>(0);
    } else {
      startColumns = new ArrayList<>(inputSchema.getFields().size());
      for (Schema.Field field : inputSchema.getFields()) {
        startColumns.add(field.getName());
      }
    }
    if (outputSchema == null || outputSchema.getFields() == null) {
      endColumns = new ArrayList<>(0);
    } else {
      endColumns = new ArrayList<>(outputSchema.getFields().size());
      for (Schema.Field field : outputSchema.getFields()) {
        endColumns.add(field.getName());
      }
    }
    FieldLevelLineage f;
    store = new DefaultTransientStore();
    registry = new CompositeDirectiveRegistry(
      new SystemDirectiveRegistry(),
      new UserDirectiveRegistry(context.getContext())
    );
    RecipeParser directives = new GrammarBasedParser(new MigrateToV2(config.directives).migrate(), registry);
    ExecutorContext ctx = new WranglerPipelineContext(ExecutorContext.Environment.TRANSFORM,
                                                      context.getContext(), store);
    try {
      // Create the pipeline executor with context being set.
      pipeline = new RecipePipelineExecutor();
      pipeline.initialize(directives, ctx);
    } catch (Exception e) {
      throw new Exception(
        String.format("Stage:%s - %s", context.getContext().getStageName(), e.getMessage())
      );
    }
    try {
      f = (new WranglerFieldLevelLineage.Builder(startColumns, endColumns)).build(pipeline.lineage());
    } catch (LineageGenerationException e) {
      LOG.warn(
        String.format("Unable to generate lineage: %s", e.getMessage())
      );
      f = null;
    }
    LOG.info(
      "Field-level lineage generated"
    );
    // context.recordLineage(f);
  }
}
...

New REST APIs

/v3/namespaces/{namespace-id}/datasets/{dataset-id}/columns/{column-id}/lineage?start=<start-ts>&end=<end-ts>&maxLevels=<max-levels>

/v3/namespaces/{namespace-id}/streams/{stream-id}/columns/{column-id}/lineage?start=<start-ts>&end=<end-ts>&maxLevels=<max-levels>

CLI Impact or Changes

TBD

UI Impact or Changes

• Option 2: Add interface to metadata table when viewing dataset to see lineage of columns possibly by clicking on column:
  Image Removed                                                         ->   When a column is clicked on will look something like:
  Image Added    ->   
• Option 2: Show all columns at once directly on lineage tab from clicking on dataset, tab between field level and dataset level:
  Image Added
  
  

Security Impact 

Should be none, TBD

Future Work

Taking this work to completion is seen in branches 'feature/implement-transform-publishLineage' and 'feature/field-level-lineage'.

These branches show implementations of recordLineage as well as the graph that can be used to join many instances of FieldLevelLineage together.

Beginnings of designing data sets for storing the information in HBase is present in 'feature/field-level-lineage'.

Impact on Infrastructure Outages 

Storage in HBase. Key being dataset reference name + field name + ProgramRunId. For each pipeline a node is added to this key; Impact TBD.

Test Scenarios

Releases

Release 4.3.0

Release 4.4.0

Related Work

• Fixing TextDirectives and parsing of directives in general